- About Us
Enemy Combatents are a whole different matter. See, they are by legal definition neither criminals nor POWS. Now you can argue what the proper treatment SHOULD be, but there is no treaty or law here binding the US in terms of what they MUST do. I really don't mind a legitimate debate over what is and is not acceptable treatment for these people, but I can't agree with the claim that the US is violating their rights under the Geneva convention (or under domestic law).
You have made one or two other claims here that were better addressed by other posters, so I won't respond to those, especially given the length of these posts!!