This is a read-only archive. Find the latest Linux articles, documentation, and answers at the new!

The GPL doesn't work that way

Posted by: Anonymous Coward on April 12, 2002 06:19 AM
You can use GPled code as much as you like without ever making your code public, so long as you do not distribute your derivative work.

In a limited beta, it could be argued that a work is still an in-house software since all the beta testers are technically employees of the company. Thus they are not 're-distributing' the GPLed code.

This said, I believe Lindows isn't helping their case by being so mysterious ..
I advance the following scenario which might explain their position:
- you are writing application X, which currently uses GPL library Y, but for which you eventually intend to use commercial library W which is not available yet. You want to test your code, but since the ultimate goal is to be commercial, you don't want to distribute it.

What do you do? I understand the position of Lindows but conclude that the longer they hold out on giving out the source, the more people are going to get suspicious-- and it will be because, regardless of whether they are legally in the right, they are not following established practice with Linux distributions.


Return to FSF asks Lindows, "Where's the source?"